Church members hold slaves for gain..

Churches of New Testament non-slave-holding.

Colonization at Andover..

Contrast between Hebrew bond service and slavery.

Concluding address.

Cruelty in the slave-making law.

Declaration of Independence unpopular..

Cruelties of slavery..

63

269

460

62, 91

47

15

304

424

366

418

346

43

230

457

415

.....

old deeds of .

Escaping slaves permitted by Dr. Rice.
Extreme cases, vs. ordinary cases...
Equivocal position of Dr. Rice...
Force, physical, discountenanced
'Do. do. justified in using.
Fugitives from slavery..
Fugitives countenanced by Dr. Rice.
Gopher, two ends to its side..
Gradualism, Rice's zeal for..
Golden Rule, slave-holders'.

Hebrew servants property holders..
Hebrew servants were not slaves.

. 175
. 359

277

278

272

359

359

270

. 351

455
328-336

PERSONS AND PAPERS QUOTED OR ALLUDED TO BY MR. BLANCHARD.

Aristotle, 21... Apelles, 42... Assembly Gen. of Free Church of
Scotland, 224..."American Board," 458... Abbe Greguine, 236...
Rev. R. N. Anderson, 164 .. Dr. Bailey, 15... Dr. Bullard, of St.
Louis, 167....Dr. Beecher, 274....Robt. J. Breckenridge, 363....
Wm. L. Breckenridge, 115...C. M. Clay, 270, 397...Judge Catron,
54....Judge Crenshaw, 45....Dr. Cunningham, 222, 419... Dr. A.
Clarke, 456...Dr. Coke, 390....Clarkson, 275, 297....Dulany, 22,
23....Rev. Jas. Duncan, 42, 203....D:. Duncomb, 42.... Edwards
Pres't. Giesler, 231....Gregory the Great, Pope, 231....Heyrick
Elizabeth, 238... T. Kellogg, Prest. Knox College, 165...Dr. Jun-
kin, 182, 228... Professor Miller, 364.... Maimonides, 412....Mon-
tesquieu, 364.... Moore Thomas, 49.... Charles Hammond, 49....
Charles James Fox, 15....Ignatius, 15, 230.... McGuffey, W. H.
182... Rev. S. Steele, 165. ..Prof. Thornwell, J. H. 181.... United
Brethren in Christ, 330....United Associate Synod, 223....John

Newton, 179, 269...Dr. Wayland, 19....Robertson's Chas. V.....
Bishop Polk, 235... Dr. Peckard, 236...Granville Sharpe, 236...
Thompson Scoble's Scales, 238.... Mr. Pickens, of South Carolina,
294...George McDuffie, 358... Washington, 364....Dr. J. L. Wil-
son, 365, 410... Otterbein, 390.... Rev. James Smylie, 42....Slave
Richard, sexton of Danville church, 62....Slave Frederick, 94....
Slave Augusta, 113.... Hon. J. R. Giddings, 63, 109.... Hon. John
McLean, 65...Judge Shaw, 65....J. G. Whittier, 95....John Wes-
ley, 97, 362...Dr. Hill, 110....Dr. Wilson, 111... Mr. Linsley, 112
.New Orleans Picayune, 113...Synod of Kentucky, 115... Pres.
Young, 115... Dr. David Rice, 117... Rev. Francis Hawley, 118...
Dr. W. S. Plummer, 164... Rev. Mr. Smith, of Sumpter county, Ala.
164...Talleyrand, 423... Jahn, 412, 455....Prof. Stuart, 456....Dr.
Woods, 457...Dr. C. E. Stowe, 468.

MR. RICE'S

SPEECHES.

.37, 38, 212, 213

Abhorrent principles of abolitionists......

.255

Abolition principles have not abolished slavery...155, 156, 157, 253
Abolitionists not called to slave States...
American Board of Foreign Missions--report and opinions...439, 443
Answer to argument from one-bloodism, &c...
Answer to Mr. Blanchard's second argument, slave-

holding kidnapping....

Answer to Mr. Blanchard's third argument.

.125

.120, 193, 342, 369

193, 197

Apostles admitted slave-holders into church..378, 389, 407, 449, 451

Apostles never charged with abolitionism..
Baptism of infant slaves....

Blanchard's representation....

Blanchard unwilling to carry out his principles.
Blanchard's reply to second argument exposed..
Blanchard's statement concerning Rev. Mr.
Nourse, disproved

Blanchard's reply to third argument exposed.
Blanchard's admission..

259
.256

25

.52, 53, 370, 372
100, 282

.101, 102, 103, 129

Blanchard's reasons for not quoting the Bible.
Blanchard's denunciation and pity; Scott, &c.
Blanchard's contempt of German critics......
Blanchard's written answers to several arguments.
Blanchard's reply to Rice's last argument considered.
Blanchard's argument on golden rule....
Blanchard makes law of God contradictory.....

183, 186

.189

.248, 249

322, 323, 324

.340

367

371

.371, 373

.447, 448

Blanchard's argument founded on two false assumptions......452
Blanchard's statement concerning sexton of Danville church, 75, 281
Blanchard's statement concerning Rev. J. C. Stiles......76, 155, 187
Blanchard's law of Gen. Assembly, and Rev. J.
D. Paxton.....

77, 98, 99, 126, 127

Blanchard objects to going to Hebrew and Greek.... .249, 250, 338

Blanchard differs from Paul about relation of master

and slave..

Bible is Rice's "beaten track".

Biblical Repository......

Consequence of slave-holding in itself sinful..

Condition of slaves not getting worse...

Condition of slaves improving..

Convention at Detroit.

.310, 311
.250, 251

.157

.38

.55, 56

.58, 127, 128

.194

Commentators and critics of timid minds--Gro-

Constantine's laws concerning marriage of slaves..

tius, Engles, Breckenridge..
Commentators and critics....

Contradictions of abolitionists..

.251

251, 252

..287

265, 266

.341

.370

.375, 376

.435, 439, 443, 481

.446

Character of primitive Christians-reply to Blanchard
Constitution of Christian Church-reply to Blanchard.
Cruel laws and cruel treatment don't prove rela-

.473

..472

tion sinful......26, 27, 79, 80, 102, 124, 136, 137, 152, 153, 313, 314
Cruelty not essential

to slavery..........27, 28, 53, 54, 57, 100, 101, 129, 130, 142, 153
Debate-its origin...

'Debate adjourned to Monday....

Dr. Bishop's difficulties in teaching slaves..

Direct argument for abolitionism not Bible argument.

24, 337
.311
. 128
210, 211

240, 241, 242

.240, 242, 243, 248, 324, 325, 339, 344

Elder in Kentucky....

Feelings of slaves toward masters--anecdote...
First argument against abolitionism.

Fifth argument against abolitionism..

Forever-six years.

Fourth argument-golden rule.

Free Church of Scotland, and Presb. Ch. in U. S. A..

Final recapitulation....

.338, 436, 470

129, 130

.88

.445

.36, 37

. 107, 197, 198
404

.86, 89, 105, 106

.452, 475, 482

242, 281
.286, 369

.259, 434

..374

.262, 263

Hagar a slave....

Humane feelings towards slaves in slave States..
Hundred men on island......
Hebrew slavery of six years..

Hebrews bought wives-meaning of bought.
Hebrew bond-servants and apprentices...

.133

.216

.288

.200, 262, 289

.266, 343

.403, 404

Jewish sheiks and clansmen .

Kingdom of God righteousness, &c.......

Law of Presb. Church concerning treatment of slaves..

Law for stranger among Jews....

Looked through slave spectacles.....

Marriage of slaves

.374

truly valid.......35, 54, 55, 74, 75, 189, 190, 213, 214, 313, 314, 370
Master and slave not on equality with husband and wife, &c. 26, 56
Meaning of eved... .267, 290, 201, 218, 344, 378, 406, 407 443

Most unpleasant feature of abolitionism..

Our translation of Bible and word servant..

Opinion of Drs. Griffin and Spring concerning abolitionism......58

Perpetuity of servitude among Jews

.470, 471

132

451

.401

.344, 377

.32

.342

.376

Position of Methodist Church.....

Prejudice from different complexion not in Rome.

..400

.283

Reason why permission granted Jews to hold slaves.
Reasonable time; admission..

Recapitulation of arguments..

Recapitulation of Blanchard's speeches.

Reply of abolitionists to argument for Jewish slavery..

.34, 41

Rice opposed to slavery-in favor of colonization..33-4, 195-6, 251-2
Rice's doctrine and the South...

Wages; hired servant and slave.....

Wesley's directions to missionaries to West Indies..

West India emancipation....

Who shall be master?..

472, 473

..400

.253, 255, 288, 289

..311, 312